No, No, Not Again! When Does DC Comics Stand To Get Optimism for Its Cinematic Universe?

With recent news that Chris Pratt is open to a fourth Guardians of the Galaxy film with James Gunn at the helm, we thought we would saunter back and have the umpteenth discussion about DC Comics never seeming to find solace in its own cinematic brand or universe. Especially given the news that Skydance is taking over the reins, James Gunn and Peter Safran are stepping down from their roles in helming the third round of DC-turned-on-screen movie tales. And let’s dive into the egregiousness of this tale unfolding in the dying days of the DCEU and the chaotic undertaking for DC Studios.

Who’s the boss now?

Well, let’s see. If there is one thing that is more damaging to a consistent universe, it’s also the corporate shenanigans that seem to perturb the next step in such a short window of time. From 2017, we’ve dealt with Time Warner, then AT&T, then Discovery, and now Skydance. Each overseer has its own priorities and ideas for usurping Marvel Studios as the top dog in superheroes, supervillains, and everything in between. More specifically, DC tried to dazzle the world when Marvel was riding high in the wake of The Avengers in 2012 and skyrocketed from there for the rest of the decade. Man of Steel did its job ($670.1 million worldwide on a $225 million budget), but the ramifications came when DC tried “thwarting” the competition by ramming two of its biggest superheroes into a train-wreck story of the decade. More botches followed here and there, thanks to corporate tactics, bonuses, and insider reports of recklessness and abuse at the outset, before another reboot attempt in 2023.

Well, the notion of a DC interconnected universe couldn’t light the fireworks when the very idea was new, different, and exciting. Retconning its own past by forcing this transition was never going to gain much traction, even if Marvel had gone back to the well of leaning heavily on 2010s nostalgia. Does DC need to bring back Christopher Nolan, Christian Bale, or even Henry Cavill just to right all the wrongs? Yeah, good luck with that. Maybe it should consider bringing back Zack Snyder just to appease the die-hards…

Things on the latter end of the 2010s went right until COVID, and then all the chaos ensued…

At the end of the 2010s, the DCEU (or films, whatever you wish to decree) was dropping well-liked biggies like Shazam!, Wonder Woman, Joker, and Aquaman, the latter two of which topped $1 billion worldwide, with the other two earning rave reviews and carrying a sentiment that maybe all would be fine for the future of DC. Birds of Prey took a beating during COVID-era uncertainty in February/March 2020, with a mere $204 million on an $83 million budget. Under normal circumstances, it could’ve easily passed the “What else you got for me test?” while keeping things alive for a surefire sequel in Wonder Woman 1984 (after its predecessor ballooned to $824 million globally) and Matt Reeves’ The Batman in 2022 (which would earn a strong $770 million worldwide). But fate would rear its ugly head once the world shut down and streaming took over in 2020.

The pandemic tore up DC’s slate for what could be viewed at the multiplex, so it decided to pivot back to giving fans what they wanted: Zack Snyder’s official cut of his version of Justice League (for an additional $70 million for reshoots and production), reigniting the SnyderVerse discourse and bringing the “SnyderBro” fanbase back to the front of the SEO-driven discourse table well after WB and most audiences had moved on (well, depends on who you ask, but the general public probably didn’t give a s*** what happened behind the scenes back in 2016-2017). Patty Jenkins’ Wonder Woman 1984 became a sacrificial lamb in the streaming wars, despite being a mediocre product that could’ve surely fared fine under normal circumstances, like Iron Man 2 or Thor: The Dark World. The Suicide Squad also joined this club, despite excellent reviews and bankrolling some worthwhile TV spinoffs for (HBO) Max. The Batman was delayed for release until 2022, and oh yeah, all the crap in between that dismantled every ounce of DC going forward, such as:

Warner Bros. getting bought by AT&T in 2018 and then Discovery in 2022 (before Skydance just recently).

Ray Fisher’s allegations of Joss Whedon’s abuse during the set of the initial Justice League and reshoots, leading to a downfall in his career trajectory for years and Whedon disappearing from Hollywood altogether from 2020 onwards.

Gal Gadot becoming the face of cringeworthy memes/online skepticism over her performances, particularly in Justice League and Wonder Woman 1984.

Ben Affleck pulling the plug on the new Batman film and putting in his papers after The Flash, while noting his alcohol abuse issues during Justice League.

Ezra Miller and his criminal infractions (in Hawaii), harassment accusations, and mental breakdown prior to his solo film’s release. And disappearing from Hollywood since the release of The Flash.

The bombing of The Flash as one of the biggest box-office bombs in film history, even with the involvement of Ben Affleck, Gal Gadot, Michael Keaton, and George Clooney in arbitrary cameos of sorts.

Amber Heard failing to convince the general public to take her side after slandering Johnny Depp with abuse allegations that led to an infamous live-recorded 2023 trial she ended up losing, and for folks calling for her removal from Aquaman and The Lost Kingdom.

Dwayne Johnson attempting (and failing) to position Black Adam as the new face of DC, which ended up tarnishing his reputation and forcing a universe-wide shutdown/reboot after miserable reviews and a pathetic box-office performance.

Henry Cavill was fired from his role as Superman shortly after the post-credits of Black Adam, amid the news of another reboot and the cancellation of any plans for a Man of Steel 2.

Batgirl was canceled and shelved by WB for testing poorly with test audiences in late 2022.

Oh, and no plans for a Justice League sequel, no matter if Zack Snyder was ever going to be involved.

All of this, along with the general decline in the marketplace for DC/Marvel, made the remaining DCEU films almost redundant, à la Shazam: Fury of the Gods, Blue Beetle, and Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom. Now, was this inevitable? Not necessarily, but whatever happened happened and couldn’t have happened any other way. So a reboot ensued, but just because Superman made $620 million worldwide last year doesn’t mean Supergirl was ever going to be a hit (and it ended up bombing, with the second installment of the reboot grossing only $127 million globally). And just because The Batman made $770 million in 2022 doesn’t mean its sequel cannot crash and burn (maybe not as an overall product, but keep tabs on the box office, especially after the long wait for its release).

Do we come out of the other end hopeful, or with a general understanding that this is the “new normal”?

Objectively speaking, the Marvel/DC train that ruled in the 2010s will most likely never be repeated again. The current generation of young(er) moviegoers has understandably less interest in fantastical action tentpoles, and not every film like The Avengers begets the necessity of spawning another universe from an outdated IP (just ask the recent Street Fighter). Probably the only interconnected universe that has remained intact since its inception would be the Conjuring series.

Anyway, the point is folks want more original stories, not something to spawn another interconnected universe or fuel hopes of seeing another one. Yours truly doesn’t think anyone will give a rat’s a** about a second version of Wonder Woman or Aquaman, any more than they were remotely interested in a spinoff of your successful flight with the red-and-blue-caped superhero last year. WB couldn’t make a DC cinematic universe work in the best of times for superhero movies; there’s no reason it will perform better anytime now, even with new owners in charge or a former Marvel executive in the role.

Leave a comment